First of all, hats off to Shankar for bringing Indian cinema in some way or the other, at par with Hollywood. A great plot and a wonderful concept, but then it had a very broken up and scattered screenplay which couldn't hold on the perfect idea that Shankar had in his brain. A little shorter version of this movie would have been much more appealing. It was just like, you have excellent seeds to sow but then you don't know when and where to sow them to reap the best crops out of it. This definitely doesn't mean in any way that his effort has gone in vain rather he has shown the path, a path for the betterment and equalization of Indian cinema with the so called "Hollywood".
Special effects were the USP of this movie and apart from the sequence of Rajini robot saving people from fire in a building, all other shots with special effects were just amazing or in my words "simply awesome". The last 30 minutes just throws all your senses into a frame where you can't argue anymore if India is capable of making high quality cinema with advanced special effects.
So, on the Special effects front i just have two words "Bravo Shankar".
The cinematography was fine and could have been little better. I guess after spending so much they could have extended it a little further and hired Christopher Pop, whom i feel, has given one of the best cinematographic efforts in an Indian cinema so far. The choreography was pretty mediocre and can be neglected as it was never bound to be a key feature for Robot. The worse part of the movie was the songs. Now i have two stands on it. Maybe it was because of the dubbing of songs in Hindi which ruined them or Rahman truly didn't perform up to his standards and then I felt it was a mix of both. It was an addition to Rahman's latest series of underperforming projects and was pretty disappointing. This movie would have been much more perfect without songs which were highly unbearable. The dialogues were pretty fine and it was clearly visible that Shankar has taken personal care that the whole translation and dubbing part goes well and comes out as decent as possible, though i personally felt it could still have been better.
Now comes the part which defines every feature that has been described so far, the performances from the two actors who are considered to be amongst the finest of all.
After watching Robot, one thing which I am sure of is that I have really taken up a great task of starting off with this movie. The reason being, though it was a great piece of work weighing up several aspects, it still was made with a regional touch and wasn't designed considering a global or even an Indian point of view. It was tough to watch it with a critical point of view because it wasn't made for that purpose. Rather it was a perfect example of the typical mainstream masala flick which does have a sense of logic added to it too and thus in a way was never expected to be watched as a critic but as a bedazzled spectator and witness the quality and excellence of Shankar, and the charm and aura of Superstar Rajini.
Overall Verdict: 6.5/10

Great review! All aspects accounted for...
ReplyDeleteAll this hype and hoopla is too much for me now... booking a ticket right away.
Thanks for the heads up :-)
sahi tomer phod diya tune to..
ReplyDelete1st yr ki yaad aa gyi padh k jab apan log movie reviewz diya krte the sabko ;P
lage rahoooo... :)
nice.. a complete round up on all aspects . i m waiting to watch the movie.. after this i guess i ll go n give it a shot.. just for the fx.
ReplyDeletei didnt read d review ...but it must be good keepin in mind d pain u have taken 2 write it....congrats and dis deserves a party
ReplyDelete@aziz n vaishnavi : thnx
ReplyDelete@thakku: hmmm...ab kisi na kisi ko to badhana hi tha
@pranav: bhai padh ke hi comment kr deta :P
Sunny....why don't ya try working as a critic for Rotten Tomatoes ? They pay handsomely...and what's more...it's fun !
ReplyDeletehmmm...i guess its not abt me considering thm and more about they considering me i guess...i wil look into it...was checking it out yesterday
ReplyDeleteNice one dude! and I completely agree that rehman is not living up to his standards...
ReplyDeleteLiked it ! Rajni carries the charisma which is not carried by any other celebrity in India. The only factor which made Robot possible. 160 crore SciFi movie in Indian cinema possible.
ReplyDeleteekdum Yo review likha hai.....
ReplyDeleteI too agree on certain things like music was really disappointed with AR rahman.....
Movie cld hv been shorter...like the mosquitos scenes were not essential at all.....Ask was beautiful as well as ravishing in the movie :)
talking first about the movie, the story is good, its a very simple and logical movie, like when chitti was asked a question about the existence of god, he asks that person to define god, and from that definition he very logically inferes the existence as possible; and even though vasee tried really hard to program emotions in chitti, going as far as responsive hormones, it was the lightening struck by a higher power that gave him emotions;
ReplyDeletei loved the songs, if u dont listen to the words at all, the beautiful locations and seductive aish is kinda pleasant to watch; the costumes of aish in the songs are really good, i hate to admit, she did look beautiful, all the skin tight latex pants, fancy head gears, the gowns, the pouted lips, diff hair styles and seductive moves... awesome... you cant ignore aish in this movie, though she got only five dialogues and five kisses...
rajini does look old, with rusted hinges and arthritic fingers, but neverthless a true superstar, i am a rajini fan since i saw mutthu maharaj, and if u ppl liked 'bhool bhulaiya' you gonna adore the original movie starring rajini...
the one reason i like bollywood over hollywood is movie length, i prefer movies to be atleast 3 hrs long...
now talking about this blog, a very positive glowing kinda writing style, no out of proportion sentences, a very personal way of writing, still content could have been better, the metaphors are lame, its long but not crisp, the short and sweet versions on facebook seem better to me, you aint here to impress anyone, write for yourself, not to prove your writing skills to readers...
in short, i loved this blog as much as i loved this movie...
I am sorry to say, but Indian cinema chahe kuch bhi karle, hollywood ka muqabla nahi kar paayegi....Robot is a pathetic movie...horrible..and the last 30 mins was even more horrible.. I deleted the movie from my hard disk..the only reason y it worked was because of rajni's fan following...
ReplyDelete@shiva: bhai tu to senti ho gaya...sabse badi aur imp galti ki tune laptop pr movie dekhi...movie ki USP wahin khatam ho gayi...its Special effects
ReplyDeleteso many people loved Bhoot...i dint...u know y...coz i watched it on TV. A movie which is meant to be scene at a specific place should be seen only there. Robot was one.
Aur last 30 mins unhi hollywood ke logon ne banaye the jinhone Jurassic Park, Predators,Aliens,Iron Man etc me kaam kiya hai n here u got all such effects in atleast less than 10 times the money tht wud hv been spent on these effects there :)